Peptide University · Module 13 · Lesson 1 of 3

Hierarchy of evidence and development phases

Critical appraisal of scientific evidence

Reading time: ~2 min · Part of the free certification in peptide science

Not all studies are worth the same. Knowing which rung the evidence for a compound is on is the most useful skill in this course, because most of the literature on research peptides sits on the lowest rungs.

1

In vitro

Isolated cells or enzymes. Useful for mechanisms; it says nothing about dose, distribution or effect in an organism.

2

Animal models

They integrate pharmacokinetics and physiology, but with species differences, per-kilo doses and artificial disease models.

3

Case series and observational studies in humans

No randomized control group; susceptible to selection bias and the placebo effect.

4

Randomized clinical trials

Control group, randomization and, ideally, double blinding. They are the standard for establishing efficacy.

5

Systematic reviews and meta-analyses

They integrate several trials; their quality depends on that of the studies included.

The clinical phases

PhaseMain questionTypical size
Phase 1Is it safe? How does it behave in the body?Dozens of people
Phase 2Does it have an effect? At what dose?Hundreds
Phase 3Does it work against the standard, in a broad population?Thousands
Phase 4What happens after approval, in the long term?Real-world population

Surrogate endpoints

A surrogate endpoint is a marker measured instead of the outcome that really matters: IGF-1 instead of body composition, a laboratory value instead of clinical events. They are useful for deciding whether to keep investigating, but improving a marker does not guarantee improving the outcome. The FDA's review of tesamorelin made this explicit: approving it for visceral fat reduction in a specific population does not validate that endpoint for other conditions.

🧭 Always locate the rung

Before assessing a result, ask: in cells, in animals or in people? With a control group? With which endpoint? The answer completely changes the weight of the claim.

Catalogue compounds mentioned in this lesson

Take the module 13 quiz and earn your certificate

The certification is free: read the lessons, pass each module quiz and the final exam, and download your PDF certificate with a verifiable ID.

Go to the quiz →

Educational content for scientific purposes. It distinguishes preclinical from clinical evidence and is not medical advice, diagnosis or a recommendation for use. NeoPeptidos products are sold labelled for research use only (RUO).